How to finish your gift list without impulse-buying junk
December 16, 2025
-
Prep in 5 minutes: list sizes + backups, snap every receipt, commit to in-store returns
-
Use rewards like coupons: search email/apps, redeem reward points now, try to split transactions to reuse perks
-
Keep gifts low-risk: check inventory + pickup, buy sets/accessories, trade in old games for credit
For many shoppers, those last-minute Christmas shopping trips often go sideways for two reasons. First, you end up paying the panic tax in the form of shipping upgrades and might as well impulse buys. Second, you inevitably end up with a bunch of stuff youll have to return in January.
So, heres my frugal playbook to help you finish your shopping this year and hopefully keep your sanity and more of your hard-earned money.
Before you walk-in, try this 5-minute setup
Make a list with the sizes and backup options youre shopping for. If you dont know a shoe size, dont buy shoes. Instead, buy the gift card + small add-on combo gift instead.
Start a Receipts album on your phone. Try to photograph every receipt the second you get it as itll save you a bunch of headaches later.
Decide your return strategy now: in-store returns = usually free. Mail-in returns can come with fees at some retailers (more on that below).
1. Macys: use the buy now, adjust later trick
The hack: Typically, if you buy something and it drops in price within 10 days, Macys will do a price adjustment. But for the holidays, theyre price matching anything bought on or after November 30thall the way up until December 25th.
How to use this policy last-minute:
- Buy the safe gifts now. Think items like coats, cookware, and small appliances.
- Then set a reminder on your phone to check the price later this week or next.
- If the price drops, and it often will, request the price adjustment (keep screenshots).
Frugal return move: If you think you might return an item, plan to return the product in-store. Macys in-store returns are free, but nonStar Rewards members will have to pay a whopping $9.99 which will be deducted from your refund.
2. Old Navy: treat Super Cash like a coupon
The hack: If you have Old Navy Super Cash sitting around, the worst thing you can do is forget to redeem it completely. Old Navy actually allows Rewards members to convert unused Cash Coupons to points within 30 days after the last day to redeem.
Each Cash Coupon dollar amount converts to 1 program point. Many loyal Old Navy shoppers arent aware that this conversion is possible, so make sure you take advantage and dont let your Cash Coupons expire.
How to use it last-minute:
- Before you head to the mall, be sure to search your email for Super Cash.
- If you find that your redemption window is not active, pivot to basics that are still worth buying (pajamas, kids layers, giftable fleece).
- If youre still within the redemption window, be sure to convert your cash to points if youre a Rewards member, instead of losing it completely.
Smart gifts at Old Navy (fast, low-risk):
- Family pajamas (easy win)
- Gloves/beanies, cozy socks bundles
- Kids basics + a pick your favorite color later note for picky kids
3. American Eagle/Aerie: use the app as your free inventory detective
The hack: The AEapp tells you whether or not an item is in-stock at a store near you. Thats a very handy feature when shopping for last-minute gifts when sizes on many popular items get wiped clean quickly.
How to use it last-minute:
- First, search for the item in the app, then check which location has the size youre looking for.
- If youre truly racing the clock, be sure to use in-store pickup. AE says items marked as Free Pickup Today can be ready in about 2 hours.
Gift ideas that dont backfire:
- Aerie: loungewear, bralettes (if you know their vibe), cozy sets
- AE: hoodies, flannels, denim (only if you know size)
4. Victorias Secret / PINK: split transactions to use more rewards
The hack: Victorias Secret allows you to apply up to 3 Member Rewards per purchase. So, if you have more than that, heres the trick so you dont waste any of them.
How to use it last-minute:
- If you have 5 rewards, be sure to do two separate transactions (3 rewards on one, 2 on the other).
- VS also allows up to 2 compatible offer codes per order (keep in mind that rewards apply separately when youre logged in).
Low-risk gift moves here:
- Fragrance mists + lotion set (easy to exchange)
- Robe/slippers
- PINK lounge sets (these are size-friendly)
5. Sephora: turn points into instant savings
The hack: If youre a Sephora Beauty Insider member you get $10 off for every 500 points earned. And you can only use the $10 discount once per transaction, on a minimum $10 purchase.
Its actually one of the better free loyalty programs around, but many members forget to redeem their $10. This serves as your reminder to use it on any last-minute gifts this year.
How to use it last-minute:
- If youre at/over 500 points and youre buying gifts anyway, redeem the $10.
- Keep in mind that you can only use one $10 reward per transaction. So if youve got 1,000+ points and youre buying multiple gifts anyway, splitting into two transactions lets you redeem it twice (500 points each time).
Low-risk Sephora gifts:
- Mini sets (fragrance, skincare, hair)
- Best of samplers
- A gift card + a travel-size add-on (looks thoughtful, avoids shade-matching disasters)
6. Bath & Body Works: join rewards before you pay
The hack:Bath & Body Works loyalty program is pretty darn solid and you should consider joining it before doing any last-minute shopping. Specifically, youll earn 10 points for every $1 spent and 1,000 points will get you a completely free product up to $16.50 in value.
How to use it last-minute:
- If youre buying multiple gifts, put them on one account so you hit the reward faster.
- If youre close to the threshold, add one practical item (like hand soap) to cross it and earn the freebie.
Fast gift ideas here:
- Hand soap bundles (teacher gifts)
- Candle + wallflower set
- Mens body care sets (easy)
7. H&M: grab the welcome offer, then use points like a coupon
The hack:H&Ms membership page lists a welcome offer for 10% off your next purchase. Plus, youll earn points on every purchase. Specifically, $1 equals 1 point and 200 points = a $5 reward.
How to use it last-minute:
- If youre not a member, sign up and get the 10% off welcome deal.
- Put all your H&M gifts in one transaction so your points will stack faster.
Smart H&M gifts:
- Accessories (scarves, beanies, gloves)
- Basics (tees, socks) + a small fun item (holiday pajamas)
8. Nordstrom Rack: returns are easy in-store, not-so-free by mail
The hack: Nordstrom Rack says store purchases can be returned for a full refund within 30 days, and you can return to any Nordstrom or Nordstrom Rack store for free.
But it also states for returns by mail, a $9.95 returns shipping charge is deducted from your refund for everypre-paid label used.
How to use it last-minute:
- Buy risky gifts only if youre willing to do in-store returns.
- Photograph receipts immediately and keep the tags attached.
Best Rack gifts:
- Designer accessories (wallets, scarves)
- Beauty sets at a discount
- Athleisure basics
9. GameStop: trade-in credit can fund last-minute gifts
The hack: If youve got old games/controllers/consoles, consider trading them in for free money that you can use on your last-minute gifts this year.
GameStops trade-in page notes that youll get the highest trade value when products are in good condition and have all necessary components. They'll determine the exact value of your trade when you visit a GameStop location.
How to use it last-minute:
- Bring chargers, cables, cases, anything that came with it.
- Use your credit for stocking stuffers like digital currency cards, accessories, headsets, etc. These gift ideas are much easier than guessing someones exact wish-list game.
