Simple moves to stretch every gift card dollar
October 27, 2025
- Know the rules, then use them fast: Balances last 5 years; inactivity fees after 12 months; some states cash out small leftovers (e.g., CA
- Buy low, sell smart: Warehouse clubs = easy 20% off; sell via eBay for max value or Raise/CardCash for quick cash
- Add cards to your phone, photo front/back + receipt, set 30/60-day reminders, spend risky retailers quickly, and zero outprepaid balances by buying an Amazon e-gift for the exact amount
Americans buy billions of dollars worth of gift cards every year and then a shocking amount sits unused in walletsand junk drawers. A whopping $244 per person on average according to a Bankrate survey.
It's time tofix that. Heres a no-nonsense gift card playbook including tips to make them easier to use, howto buy cards at a discount, where to sell the duds, and how to keep from losing them.
First, the gift card rules worth knowing
Expiration:By federal law, the money on most gift cards cant expire for at least five years. If there's a date on the card and it expires, youre entitled to a free replacement from the store or brand with your remaining balance.
Fees: Dormancy/inactivity fees generally cant hit until 12 months of no use and even then, only once per month and only if they've warned you about this ahead of time.
Small leftover balances: Some states let you cash out smallerbalances. For example, California requires cash back on most store cards under $10. Ask at the customer service desk if this is an option in your state.
What this means for you:My general rule of thumb is to use cards sooner rather than later and thereby avoid store closures, policy changes, and plain old forgetfulness.
The best places to buy gift cards below face value
- Warehouse clubs: Costco, Sams Club, and BJs regularly sell popular restaurant and entertainment cards at 5%25% off. I often buy gift cards at Costco as you can buy a 4-pack of $25 gift cards for only $79.99, an easy 20% savings. Its nice to get the savings up front. If you already have a membership, this is the easiest win.
Reputable online marketplaces:
- Raise - The savings is not as good as a warehouse club, typically in the 3% -15% range. They offer a 90-day money back buyer guarantee which covers you if you buy an inactive card, get an inaccurate balance, or if the wrong card gets mailed to you.
- CardCash - They are similar to Raise, but they only offer a 45-day guarantee on their gift cards. But unlike Raise, they offer they ability to trade an unwanted card for other brands, sometimes giving you a better return than cashing out.
Pro tip: If you dont like fine print, stick to the warehouse clubs when buying gift cards. If youre comfortable following a couple of steps, marketplaces have the potential to save you more, just be sure to spend the balance right away.
The best places to sell unwanted gift cards
Have a card you wont use? Cashing out is better than letting it gather dust.
These fouroptions are worth a strong look:
- eBay Selling gift cards on eBay has the highest upside if the store or brand is hot and you run an auction or "Buy It Now" at market price. But keep in mind that category restrictions and selling fees do apply.
- GiftCash.com A very straightforward option: you enter the brand and balance and get back an instant cash offer. If you accept the offer, they'll pay you via ACH or PayPalafter verifying the card.
- Raise - You can list and set your price (youll pay a fee when it sells). Good for popular brands than move quickly.
- CardCash Theyll give you a quick quote for cash or trade which is handy. Expect less than face value, but its simple process and fast.
Reality check: You wont get dollar-for-dollar cash back when selling at the above spots. Popular stores fetch more and niche brands fetch less. Still, 7590% is common enough that it beats losing the whole thing.
Dont lose them: 5 tips that actually work
1. Add it to your phone right away.Many store and Apple Account cards can be redeemed/managed right in Wallet; follow the on-screen Redeem steps and itll live on your phone until you need it.
2. Photograph everything. Front, back, and the receipt. If a balance ever goes missing, you'll be able to use those photos asevidence with the issuer or marketplace.
3.Set a use-it reminder. Tell your phone to remind you in 30 days and again in 60 days. If you havent used the gift cardby then, plan a shopping trip or sell it.
4. Register the card if the brand allows it. Registration can help if the card is lost or if theres suspicious activity. (Not every brand offers this, but check.)
5. Spend store-specific cards quickly if you see bad news. If a retailer is rumored to be closing or restructuring, dont wait, use it SAP. Whether gift cards get honored can depend on a courts decision so spend it quickly.
Use-it-soon strategies (so the value doesnt vanish)
Attach the card to a real errand. For example, if you have a restaurant card in your wallet, put a lunch on the calendar this week. Have a Home Depot or Lowes gift card? Buy the air filters and light bulbs youre going to need anyway.
Keep track of your balance and split it smartly. For example, tell the cashier, Please put $X on this gift card and the rest on my credit card. That zeros out the card so youre not stuck with $2.17 forever.
Know your states cash-out rule. In some places you can ask for cash back on small leftovers (e.g., under $10 in California, under $5 in Oregon and Washington). Its worth a quick ask at customer service.
Smart way to use a remaining balance on a prepaid card
Chances are theres a mostly-spent prepaid Visa/Mastercard cash card in your wallet and youre not sure what to do with the leftovers.
Turn it into cash to spend on Amazon, right down to the last cent.
Heres what you do, find the exact remaining balance, then buy an Amazon gift card for that amount and add it to your account. Then you can toss the prepaid card knowing youve accounted for every cent.
Here are the exact steps:
- On Amazon, buy an e-gift card for yourself - Go to Gift Cards eGift Card (or Reload your balance), choose Custom amount, and enter the exact card balance. Set delivery to your own email.
- Register a billing ZIP (important) - On the cards website, add your name, address, and ZIP. Amazon runs an address match and unregistered cards often decline.
- Buy the gift card with the prepaid card only - At checkout, add the prepaid card (as a new credit card) and make sure no other card is selected when paying.
- Redeem instantly - Open the email youll get from Amazon, click Apply to your balance, and youve consolidated that odd leftover into your Amazon Gift Card balance.
Pro tip: Avoid trying to split an Amazon order across multiple credit cards. Amazon doesnt support split tender (gift card + credit card).
How to give a gift card the right way
I have two simple rules when it comes to gifting a gift card along with a couple of niceties:
- Give a brand they already use. Grocery, gas, pharmacy, Target, Amazoncards that disappear into everyday spending get used fastest (and are less likely to be lost).
- Avoid activation-fee traps when possible. Those general-purpose Visa/Mastercard gift cards sometimes charge purchase fees. If you want flexibility, consider a major merchant instead.
What if something goes wrong?
Did your balance disappear on a secondhand card? File a claim with the store or brand and include any evidence you might have like screenshots or receipts showing your previous balance.
Did the retailer suddenly stop accepting cards? If you just bought the gift card on a credit card and the retailer stopped honoring cards (e.g., due to a closure or bankruptcy), ask your card issuer for a chargeback for goods/services not provided.