Consumer News: Potential tariffs risk turning Italian pasta into a luxury item

Microsoft says it will appeal the ruling, which strikes at the heart of its business model

UK tribunal says Microsoft licenses can be legally resold
Ruling rejects Microsofts copyright claim; company plans to appeal
Decision clears path for resellers 270M damages case to proceed

Microsoft says it will challenge a decision by the UK Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) that strikes at the heart of its long-standing restrictions on reselling software licenses. The tribunal ruled that perpetual licenses for products such as Windows and Microsoft Office can legally be resoldrejecting Microsofts argument that such activity infringes its copyright.

The case dates back to 2021, when UK reseller ValueLicensing sued Microsoft over contractual terms that barred customers from reselling previously issued licenses. The reseller argued that these restrictions violated the principles of the European Software Directive and had cost the company millions in lost revenue.

Microsoft initially fought the claim on contractual grounds, but later advanced a copyright infringement theory. Because Office programs include interface elements such as icons and graphics, the company argued they should be treated as original artistic works, making license resale a copyright violation.

Judges dismissed that argument, saying the presence of such graphics does not convert software licenses into copyrighted creative works that restrict resale. Customers holding perpetual licenses are free to resell them, the tribunal saidechoing a decade-old precedent set in the UKs UsedSoft case.

The ruling could make it easier and cheaper for UK consumers and businesses to obtain Windows 11 or Office through the secondary market if it holds up on appeal.

ValueLicensing says decision validates its business

ValueLicensing has always believed it was running a legitimate business underpinned by the principles of the European Software Directive and the UsedSoft judgment at the ECJ, the companys managing director said following the ruling. This judgment confirms these principles, which legitimately allowed ValueLicensing to save its customers money on used Microsoft software.

The company said it now plans to refocus on the core of its lawsuit, which seeks damages for what it alleges were unlawful restrictions that hampered its business.

Case moves to damages phase and more litigation awaits

With the copyright argument dismissed, Microsoft will need a new defense as the lawsuit proceeds. If it ultimately loses, the company could face millions in damages to ValueLicensing.

But the financial risk doesnt end there. Microsoft is also tied up in a separate, similar class-action suit alleging abuse of market dominance and anti-competitive licensing practicesexposure that could reach into the billions.

For a company long accustomed to accusations of restrictive contracts and inflated pricing, the latest rulings add to a familiar pattern of legal headaches. Yet with Microsofts valuation supercharged by the AI boom, the litigation may amount to little more than a costly distraction for the tech giant.

New ADT insights reveal how common shortcuts leave families more vulnerable than we think

• Many common home-security habits like relying on fake cameras or leaving doors unlocked offer comfort, not real protection.

• New ADT data shows 72% of people who use these shortcuts admit theyre only occasionally effective at preventing theft or break-ins.

• Experts say upgrading to real, connected security devices with professional monitoring is the best way to keep your home truly safe.

When it comes to protecting our homes, many of us lean on habits that feel smart but dont actually keep us safer.

Maybe youve stuck a fake camera above the garage, rely on a Protected by sign from a hardware store, or assume nothing bad will happen if you leave the front door unlocked just this once.

Outdated methods of home protection

According to new ADT data, these shortcuts may be doing more harm than good.

The numbers are eye-opening: 38% of Americans use decoy security items, and another 38% admit they regularly or occasionally leave their front door unlocked. Even more striking, 72% of people who depend on these habits say theyre only sometimes effective at preventing break-ins or theft.

ConsumerAffairs interviewed Jimmy Lin, Vice President of Product Management at ADT to learn more about these behaviors and how consumers can actually stay safe.

Criminals know whats fake

According to Lin, these methods are increasingly less effective as criminals learn the common decoys and safe-ish security habits.

They can often spot a fake camera or notice when a sign doesnt match the equipment on the house which can identify your house as an even bigger target, he said. And with the false sense of security they provide, homeowners can neglect important measures like locking doors and windows, leaving them at risk.

Lin explained that homeowners are ultimately the ones at risk when they opt for these types of safety measures.

The biggest risk with using safe-ish practices is thinking you're protected when you're not, Lin said. It can lead people to let their guard down, delay real action, or ignore signs of vulnerability. Our research found that 72% of people who rely on these kinds of habits admit theyre only occasionally effective, proving its not worth the risk.

Prioritize safety

Homeowners are encouraged to adopt real, trusted security measures to ensure safety in their homes.

To be truly safe, replace decoys with real, connected devices from a trusted security brand, Lin said. Complete with indoor and outdoor security cameras, door and window sensors, security alarms, and motion sensors, a full security system especially one with 24/7 professional monitoring is the best way to keep you and your home safe at all times.

Security systems also allow you to have alerts whether its for motion detection, package delivery, or an open door, so you know whats happening in real time."

Why fraudulent ads, fake websites, and rushed clicks are more common than ever during Black Friday

• Scammers are using Black Friday buzz to disguise fake ads, bogus storefronts, and too-good-to-be-true deals.

• Fraud experts say red flags include sites with endless high-demand products and failed payments meant to harvest card numbers.

• Shoppers can protect themselves by sticking to trusted retailers, using official apps, and adopting a trust but verify mindset before buying.

Black Friday has become the unofficial kickoff to holiday shopping and scammers know it.

Fraudsters are already working overtime to grab a piece of your wallet, from misleading ads to fake websites designed to look like your favorite retailers, the risks are higher than most people realize.

ConsumerAffairs interviewed Scamnetic CEO Al Pascual to learn about the biggest threats this year that are hiding in plain sight.

Biggest scam risks

With consumers shopping more during the holidays, its the perfect time for scammers to strike.

Criminals take advantage of the holidays to better camouflage their activities, hiding them within and among legitimate activity, Pascual said. Black Friday provides the perfect cover to offer 'too good to be true' deals on in-demand products under the auspices of a seemingly legitimate e-commerce site.

And as the holiday season passes, deals and hard-to-get gifts will become even more appealing to unfortunate victims who take the bait.

Red flags of a scam

Pascual also shared some of the red flags consumers should be aware of this holiday season.

If a consumer visits a site that seemingly has a wide array of in-demand products, that is a sign that they may have found themselves on a fake storefront, he said.

Another potential sign is if the site is unable to process your payment, despite changing the card being used. This could indicate that the site was designed to harvest card numbers from victims.

Protecting yourself this holiday season

While scammers may be running rampant this holiday season, consumers can still do everything in their power to protect themselves and their personal information.

The best thing consumers can do to avoid being scammed is to shop with trusted merchants directly through apps from the Google Play store or the Apple App store, Pascual said.

Scammers play on our trust. The best mindset is unfortunately one of constant skepticism, or put another way, consumers should 'trust but verify' before they ever share sensitive information and make a payment.

Basketball and football also are close behind

• New analysis finds cycling, basketball, and football lead the nation in ER-treated sports injuries
• Cycling alone sent more than 450,000 riders to the hospital in 2024, a 12% increase from the previous year
• Legal experts warn youth and amateur leagues often fail to protect participants from liability risks

Cycling has officially become Americas most dangerous sport, according to a new study by Florida-based Anidjar & Levine Personal Injury Lawyers. The two-year analysis found that cyclists suffered 859,696 emergency room-treated injuries in 2023 and 2024more than any other sport.

The firms researchers combined total injury counts, year-over-year changes, and injury rates per 100,000 participants to develop a Sports Danger Score. Cyclings score of 88.22 put it well ahead of basketball and football, which ranked second and third.

The data show cycling injuries climbed from 405,688 in 2023 to more than 454,000 in 2024, a 12% increase. With an injury rate of 133 per 100,000 riders, the sports risks stem from collisions, high-speed falls, and limited physical protection.

Cycling presents unique legal challenges because incidents often involve multiple parties, from motorists to municipalities responsible for road conditions, said Marc Anidjar, founding senior partner of the firm. Riders need to understand their rights and the liability landscape, especially when infrastructure fails to provide adequate safety measures.

Basketball and football also rank high

Basketball placed second on the danger list, with 718,168 total injuries over the two-year span. The sports injury rate of 113 per 100,000 participants reflects its fast pace and frequent player contact. Injuries jumped 16% year-over-year, from 332,391 in 2023 to 385,777 in 2024.

In organized basketball, from youth leagues to adult recreational programs, the question of liability often centers on supervision and facility maintenance, Anidjar said. Determining whether proper safety protocols were followed becomes the key legal question.

Football, long known for its physical toll, ranked third with 581,828 injuries and a Sports Danger Score of 67.12. It also recorded the largest growth among the top three sportsinjuries surged 21% between 2023 and 2024.

Football organizations, particularly at the youth and high school levels, face increasing scrutiny over concussion protocols and equipment standards, Anidjar noted. The question isnt just whether injuries happen, but whether organizers took reasonable steps to prevent them.

Soccer and skating round out top five

Soccer ranked fourth with 478,184 injuries, up 25% from 2023. Skating, which includes skateboarding, roller skating, and scooter use, rounded out the top five with 660,544 injuriesa 27% rise in one year. Both sports had relatively lower injury rates per participant but showed rapid growth in overall ER visits.

Recreational leagues and public facilities often operate with minimal oversight and unclear liability, said Anidjar. Waivers dont always hold up in court if a facility was poorly maintained or supervision was inadequate.

Legal protections often fall short

Anidjar warned that many amateur and youth sports organizations lack adequate safety standards, insurance, and legal compliance. Liability and safety regulations vary widely across sports, he said. Informed consent requires more than a signatureparticipants need to understand the specific risks and what happens if they get hurt.

He added that organizations must ensure proper equipment, qualified supervision, and adherence to established safety rules. When these elements are missing, legal liability becomes a very real concern.

The top 10 most dangerous sports in America

Methodology

The analysis used data from the National Safety Councils Injury Facts database for 2023 and 2024, focusing on emergency department-treated sports injuries. The Sports Danger Score combined total injuries, annual changes, and injury rates per 100,000 participants, with a higher score indicating greater risk.

Credit: Data and analysis courtesy of Anidjar & Levine Personal Injury Lawyers.